Waymo suspends all US highway operations after safety failures

Waymo, the world’s leading robotaxi operator, is suspending highway operations across the United States. The nationwide stop follows California’s motor vehicle regulator declaring its driverless freeway operations an imminent hazard to public safety.

The decision is a setback for an industry that is fully preparing to embark in Europe.

Two incidents

The California Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) has modified Waymo’s deployment permit. The state regulator added a restriction that bars its vehicles from operating or testing on the state’s freeways.

That decision follows incidents that were reported with Waymo cars around active construction zones where workers, vehicles, and equipment were present. 

More precisely, two incidents from early November tipped the balance. In the first, three Waymo vehicles drove into a closed, active construction zone; the second was a somewhat wilder action captured on video that went viral last week.

The video shows how a driverless Waymo approaches a so-called traffic break on an Interstate at speed. Two California Highway Patrol cruisers, lights flashing, were deliberately slowing traffic behind a slow-moving construction truck with workers on the road.

The robotaxi arrives at high speed and first tries to pass the patrol cars on the left. One of the officers blocks it, but then Waymo goes for it a second time, this time on the right.

It’s an example of how less frequent and more complex traffic situations remain difficult for automated cars to interpret.

Safety first

The restriction stays in place until Waymo can show the DMV that it has taken effective corrective action. In practice, the regulator wants proof that the system can reliably recognize and respond to construction zones, emergency vehicles and other hazards on the road.

The DMV’s authority ends at California’s border. Yet Waymo decided to halt highway driving across all its active zones, including Phoenix, Miami and Austin. A spokesperson said the company had temporarily restricted freeway operations elsewhere to evaluate its performance, in line with its safety-first principles. 

Waymo further points out that the incidents near Burlingame caused no injuries or collisions, and that it is working with the DMV and other state officials to resume freeway driving.

On local roads, nothing changes. Waymo continues to operate on those streets in its 15 US cities, with a fleet of around 4,000 vehicles that together complete some half-million paid rides a week. Waymo maintains that its cars are involved in 95 percent fewer serious crashes than human drivers.

Insufficient fix?

Waymo has been here before. The company only began offering freeway rides in November last year, starting in the San Francisco Bay Area – faster journeys and quicker access to airports are a crucial selling point.

But in May this year, Waymo already had to pull its cars off the highways after a passenger had filmed his robotaxi driving through cones into a freeway construction zone, accelerating to highway speed and being followed by police. Around the same time, vehicles in other places were reported driving into flooded roads. 

After a safety recall, Waymo gradually resumed highway driving during the summer. The software updates performed, designed to improve performance around construction zones, apparently need further fixing.

Normally, highways are regarded as an easier environment for a self-driving car, with no traffic lights, cyclists or pedestrians to deal with. But speeds are much higher, so any mistake has far more serious consequences.

That is why regulators give freeway incidents considerably more weight than a robotaxi blocking an emergency vehicle on a city street, which still happens regularly.

The episode is also relevant to Europe, as Waymo has begun testing in London this year and aims to expand to Munich and Spain in 2027. European regulators will be watching closely how their American counterparts deal with these incidents.

Waymo’s decision to pull back nationwide is a responsible choice and a sign that the company takes the warning seriously. But it also shows that the leap from city streets to the motorway is bigger than the industry hoped. 

You Might Also Like

Create a free account, or log in.

Gain access to read this article, plus limited free content.

Yes! I would like to receive new content and updates.